Difference between revisions of "Verification/Noteworthy Products"

From Open Food Facts wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(+1)
(Salted olive oil.)
(40 intermediate revisions by 15 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
DRAFT BEING TRANSLATED
 
 
== Products with several byproducts ==
 
== Products with several byproducts ==
 
Several lists of ingredients and several nutritional tables.
 
Several lists of ingredients and several nutritional tables.
Line 24: Line 23:
 
** {{Product|4607151981118}}
 
** {{Product|4607151981118}}
 
** {{Product|4607001001638}}
 
** {{Product|4607001001638}}
 +
* {{Product|7260816747060}} Salmon and Sauce
 +
* {{Product|4008400360621}} Three products in one (also three nutrition tables)
 +
* {{Product|4810268022647}} Separate ingredients and nutrition tables for the tvorog+cream and the fruit filling, which are in separate chambers in specified quantities (the text recommends mixing them).
 +
* {{Product|7613035244320}} Two ice cream flavours, each having its own ingredient list and nutritrion table.
 +
* {{Product|8000500168554}} Two ingredient lists and nutrition tables (one for the "Grand Ferrero Rocher", and one for the 2 Ferrero Rocher inside it).
 +
* {{Product|8000500262450}} Ferrero Golden Gallery : six kinds of chocolates, each one with its ingredients list and nutritional table.
 +
* {{Product|8000500262283}} : Ferrero Golden Gallery : four kinds of chocolates, each one with its ingredients list and nutritional table.
 +
* {{Product|3021762412280}} : Materne Pom'potes : 4 kinds of products, each one with its ingredient lists and nutritional table.
 +
* {{Product|4000930527048}} Schinkenplatte/selection of meats: 4 ingredient listings, 2 nutrition tables
 +
 +
== Identical products with different branding ==
 +
 +
* {{Product|4388844217553}} and {{Product|24511506}}
 +
* "Schoko & Keks"
 +
** {{Product|4337185443275}}
 +
** {{Product|4311501478578}}
 +
** {{Product|20091170}}
 +
** {{Product|9000332811405}}
 +
** {{Product|20191900}}
 +
** {{Product|4388844276574}}
  
 
== Products with same bar code ==
 
== Products with same bar code ==
Line 32: Line 51:
 
* Chocolate ice cream with chocolate chips Picard: {{Product|3270160277605}}
 
* Chocolate ice cream with chocolate chips Picard: {{Product|3270160277605}}
 
* Organic Basmati Rice and Ethiquable Alter Eco : {{Product|3700214610121}}
 
* Organic Basmati Rice and Ethiquable Alter Eco : {{Product|3700214610121}}
 +
 +
* Images of 4 different products have been uploaded for {{Product|5901234123457}}. I can't confirm any of these with a simple web search. This EAN code is also often used for illustration purposes on e.g. Wikipedia and Python sample code
 +
** Terrafrika One Cola,
 +
** Bridelice cream or milk (not sure),
 +
** Eggo Waffles
 +
** "Diamond" dietary supplement
 +
 +
* 20550196
 +
**{{Product|20550196}}
  
 
* 29420001
 
* 29420001
Line 99: Line 127:
  
  
* ''Aldi's products:''
+
=== Aldi's products ===
 
** 22049896
 
** 22049896
 
*** Tofu ecológico "GutBio" {{Product|22049896}}
 
*** Tofu ecológico "GutBio" {{Product|22049896}}
Line 238: Line 266:
 
*** Skyr Himbeer-Cranberry - Milsa {{Product|29046256}}
 
*** Skyr Himbeer-Cranberry - Milsa {{Product|29046256}}
 
*** Skyr Aprikose-Sanddornbeere - Milsa {{Product|2000000037100}}
 
*** Skyr Aprikose-Sanddornbeere - Milsa {{Product|2000000037100}}
 +
** 26042794
 +
*** In Australia : chocolate biscuits
 +
*** In France : potato crisps
 +
** 26074870
 +
*** In Australia : Cream
 +
*** In France : Vin Chardonnay d'Afrique du Sud
 +
** 29039760
 +
*** Sahne Schokolade - Château {{Product|29039760}}  (this entry is a mix of the 3 types below)
 +
*** Herbe Sahne - Château
 +
*** Alpen Sahne - Château
 +
*** Kaffee Sahne - Château
 +
** 29016426
 +
*** Schmelzkäse Gouda - Lisani {{Product|29016426}}
 +
*** Schmelzkäse Kräuter - Lisani
 +
*** Schmelzkäse Sahne - Lisani
 +
*** Schmelzkäse Creme - Lisani
 +
** 29087297
 +
*** Truthahn-Salami Paprika - Güldenhof {{Product|29087297}}
 +
*** Truthahn-Salami Klassik - Güldenhof
 +
** 29009541
 +
*** Ziegenkäse Natur - Hofburger {{Product|29009541}}
 +
*** Ziegenkäse Kräuter - Hofburger
 +
** 29050635
 +
*** Griechischer Schafskäse, leicht - Devina {{Product|29050635}}
 +
*** Griechischer Schafskäse - Devina
  
* ''Lidl's products:''
+
=== Lidl's products ===
 
** 20036768
 
** 20036768
 
*** Milk with FR EMB codes {{Product|20036768}}
 
*** Milk with FR EMB codes {{Product|20036768}}
Line 273: Line 326:
 
*** Gaches
 
*** Gaches
 
*** Pains au lait {{Product|20065485}}
 
*** Pains au lait {{Product|20065485}}
 +
** 20085391
 +
*** Boisson lactée à base de yaourt aromatisée p^éche fruit de la passion {{Product|20085391}}
 +
*** Röstzwiebeln (Oignons frits), BASTA, 350g
  
* ''Dia's products:''
+
=== Dia's products ===
 
** 8437000305019
 
** 8437000305019
 
*** Brócoli "San Juan del Valle" {{Product|8437000305019}}
 
*** Brócoli "San Juan del Valle" {{Product|8437000305019}}
Line 280: Line 336:
  
 
== Products with two barcodes ==
 
== Products with two barcodes ==
 
 
* [http://fr.openfoodfacts.org/produit/3344290321344/amandes-crues-decortiquees-sans-marque amandes-crues-decortiquees-sans-marque]
 
* [http://fr.openfoodfacts.org/produit/3344290321344/amandes-crues-decortiquees-sans-marque amandes-crues-decortiquees-sans-marque]
 +
* [http://nl.openfoodfacts.org/product/8410223800165/turron-duro-la-bruja turrón duro]
 +
* {{product|8410223607139}} chocolat noir à l'orange - Delaviuda
  
 
== Products without barcode, but with EAN-number ==
 
== Products without barcode, but with EAN-number ==
* * {{product|3256223671030}} : chips à l'ancienne saveur moutarde de U.
+
* {{product|3256223671030}} : chips à l'ancienne saveur moutarde de U.
  
 
== Different products in different countries ==
 
== Different products in different countries ==
Line 291: Line 348:
  
 
* {{product|7612100054994}} : Ovomaltine has the same barcode but different Nutrition Facts between FR version and IT/ES/PT version (see photos)
 
* {{product|7612100054994}} : Ovomaltine has the same barcode but different Nutrition Facts between FR version and IT/ES/PT version (see photos)
 +
 +
* {{product|3083680002875}} : Bonduelle canned sweet corn seems to have different data in Russia and Georgia.
  
 
== Products with strange nutritional information ==
 
== Products with strange nutritional information ==
Line 309: Line 368:
 
* {{Product|8000500168554}}: Product has one column (nutri info and ingredients) for each kind of chocolate
 
* {{Product|8000500168554}}: Product has one column (nutri info and ingredients) for each kind of chocolate
 
* {{Product|5012035947835}}: Product has one column for nutrition facts and two sections for ingredients (2 products in one).
 
* {{Product|5012035947835}}: Product has one column for nutrition facts and two sections for ingredients (2 products in one).
 +
* {{Product|3423720012462}}: Product with 48,6 g / 100 g. A bit salty for a cake.
 +
* {{Product|3461820210425}}: Product with 2.8g of salt, which is very strange for olive oil.
 +
 +
See also: https://world.openfoodfacts.org/label/incorrect-nutrition-facts-on-label
  
 
== Products to remove ==
 
== Products to remove ==
* See [[Products to remove]]
+
See [[Verification/Products_to_delete|Products to delete]]
 
 
 
 
* {{Product|8430570061675}} - is no longer there, remove line? --[[User:Aleene|Aleene]] ([[User talk:Aleene|talk]]) 17:15, 21 August 2015 (CEST)
 
* {{Product|8410100024356}} - what is wrong here? --[[User:Aleene|Aleene]] ([[User talk:Aleene|talk]]) 17:15, 21 August 2015 (CEST)
 
* {{Product|4015600560850}} - is no longer available, remove line? --[[User:Aleene|Aleene]] ([[User talk:Aleene|talk]]) 17:16, 21 August 2015 (CEST)
 
* {{Product|4069400284300}} - is no longer available, remove line? --[[User:Aleene|Aleene]] ([[User talk:Aleene|talk]]) 17:18, 21 August 2015 (CEST)
 
* {{Product|8435064529563}} - is no longer available, remove line? --[[User:Aleene|Aleene]] ([[User talk:Aleene|talk]]) 17:18, 21 August 2015 (CEST)
 
* {{Product|8426765313056}} - is no longer available, remove line?--[[User:Aleene|Aleene]] ([[User talk:Aleene|talk]]) 17:18, 21 August 2015 (CEST)
 
* {{Product|22020406}} -- repeated product from {{Product|8480000204066}} - the last one is the "good", don't delete it!! :-)
 
* http://us.openfoodfacts.org/label/to-delete (duplicates with wrong barcodes) - no longer relevant? --[[User:Aleene|Aleene]] ([[User talk:Aleene|talk]]) 17:20, 21 August 2015 (CEST)
 
* {{Product|8712561838788}} - can be deleted, shows a shampoo
 
* http://tr.openfoodfacts.org/product/00106141410123456786/gyf
 
  
 
== Other Noteworthy Products ==
 
== Other Noteworthy Products ==
Line 343: Line 394:
 
* {{product | 4021912006023}} : some languages provide more ingredients
 
* {{product | 4021912006023}} : some languages provide more ingredients
  
== Products with multiple possible sets of ingredients ==
+
== Products with small item-dependent variations ==
 +
=== Products with multiple possible sets of ingredients ===
 
* {{Product|4810268024313}}: the letter (which is to be found near the dates on the cap) is in parentheses after the ingredient.
 
* {{Product|4810268024313}}: the letter (which is to be found near the dates on the cap) is in parentheses after the ingredient.
 
* {{Product|4601512006724}}: same, but no comma ("или" means "or"), and there is an asterisk after the letter.
 
* {{Product|4601512006724}}: same, but no comma ("или" means "or"), and there is an asterisk after the letter.
 +
 +
=== Variable nutrition data ===
 +
* {{Product|4607053473537}} and {{Product|4690228010347}} — fat and energy values are printed together with the prod./exp. dates.
  
 
== Products whose recipe has changed ==
 
== Products whose recipe has changed ==
Line 384: Line 439:
 
[[fr:Produits_remarquables]]
 
[[fr:Produits_remarquables]]
 
[[category:Special products]]
 
[[category:Special products]]
 +
[[category:Verification]]
 +
 +
== Product with a Nutri-Score that has improved over time ==
 +
Asked a lot by journalists, we should have a couple of examples to showcase
 +
* Sandwich saumon - 135 g - Sodébo {{Product|3242272890751}}
 +
* All Activia passed from C to B with the apposition of the nutriscore on their packaging (e.g. Activia au bifidus mangue - Danone - 500 g (4x125g) {{Product|3033491325519}}

Revision as of 13:10, 25 February 2021

Products with several byproducts

Several lists of ingredients and several nutritional tables.

Identical products with different branding

Products with same bar code

  • Images of 4 different products have been uploaded for (see product 5901234123457 m). I can't confirm any of these with a simple web search. This EAN code is also often used for illustration purposes on e.g. Wikipedia and Python sample code
    • Terrafrika One Cola,
    • Bridelice cream or milk (not sure),
    • Eggo Waffles
    • "Diamond" dietary supplement
  • 20408466
    • ASDA 15 eggs
    • Crackers goût Pizza Crusti Croc (LIDL)
  • Mineral waters with the same brand and codebar but from different mineral springs (and with different mineral composition).
  • Meat that has different EMB codes and other information.
    • 20472245


Aldi's products

Lidl's products

Dia's products

Products with two barcodes

Products without barcode, but with EAN-number

Different products in different countries

  • (see product 5449000011527 m) : Swiss Fanta has the same barcode as the French Fanta manu1400 but it looks like ( the picture is blurred ..) that the ingredients are different
  • (see product 7612100054994 m) : Ovomaltine has the same barcode but different Nutrition Facts between FR version and IT/ES/PT version (see photos)

Products with strange nutritional information

  • (see product 3335122723382 m): Mix information " per 100g ", " per 100ml ", " g / l "
  • Cookies brand " Michel et Augustin" , developed in Paris , formulate sentences with nutritional information and ingredients for some cookies ( not the entire package .) Ingredients "classics" are against full labeled in English , for example: (see product 3760122961951 m)
  • (see product 6132500680018 m): Presence of vitamin difficult to read (B22 ? ) .
  • (see product 3367651001303 m): the weight of a sandwich is not specified , but information are provided in the table.
  • (see product 5000183505458 m): 6.1g carbohydrates of which 6.9g sugars? There's something fishy in this tomato and smoked bacon sauce!
  • (see product 5060079730036 m): 39.63g carbohydrates of which 46.59g sugars! Another surprising sauce...
  • (see product 3250391640379 m): Value for sodium and salt incompatible
  • (see product 3250390305224 m): Value for sodium and salt incompatible
  • (see product 3700238384350 m): 52.8g carbohydrates of which 439.7g sugars!!!
  • (see product 00180115 m): Product has one column for thighs, one for drumsticks
  • (see product 5000184161028 m): nutrition facts are based on the cube diluted in water, instead of the weight of the cube itself :
  • (see product 29019373 m): nutrition facts are based on the prepared/cooked penne ("zubereitet"); while there is probably no relevant difference in the nutrition info itself, the amount of water soaked up while cooking may differ based on some conditions (salt? heat? duration?)
  • (see product 5000169403822 m): Product has one column (nutri info and ingredients) for each kind of cookie
  • (see product 7613035664692 m): Product has one column (nutri info and ingredients) for each kind of chocolate
  • (see product 8000500168554 m): Product has one column (nutri info and ingredients) for each kind of chocolate
  • (see product 5012035947835 m): Product has one column for nutrition facts and two sections for ingredients (2 products in one).
  • (see product 3423720012462 m): Product with 48,6 g / 100 g. A bit salty for a cake.
  • (see product 3461820210425 m): Product with 2.8g of salt, which is very strange for olive oil.

See also: https://world.openfoodfacts.org/label/incorrect-nutrition-facts-on-label

Products to remove

See Products to delete

Other Noteworthy Products

  • (see product 5000242452693 m): "Slow cooked tender prime steak in a rich gravy infused with Guiness beer, baked in a unique Holland's golden shortcrust pie" is probably the longest product name we stumbled upon
  • (see product 8901491101844 m): Two ingredients lists, one on an importer's sticker. Importer's sticker is more specific, but manufacturer's list includes an E-code for an unlisted ingredient (160b).
  • (see product 9100000819136 m) : Diabetic information in nutrition facts.
  • Veggie Aufschnitt in two flavors (see product 22148186 m)
  • (see product 4311596460434 m): Product by several producers (DE NI 010 EG and DE NI 059 EG) with different nutritions and labels (DLG 2012). Might be they changed producers, but Edeka probably sells enough units to need more than one producer at the same time.
  • (see product 4300175075589 m): Mineral water from several water sources (Noe-Quelle, Quintus-Quelle) with different nutrition values. Also only one is "Natriumarm".

Preparing for foods

Their peculiarity is that it requires an array of unique nutritional values ​​, because the values ​​of the product as it does not really make sense , I do not know whether to put in the database the two values ​​, or alternatively, if must keep one, I think the nutritional value of the product when prepared is more interesting because it is what we want . (Currently I put the values ​​of the product as it is waiting for a ARMONISATION ) - Syaoran ] ] ([ [ User talk : Syaoran | discussion ) September 22, 2013 at 21:32 (CEST)

Products with different ingredients in multiple languages

Products with small item-dependent variations

Products with multiple possible sets of ingredients

  • (see product 4810268024313 m): the letter (which is to be found near the dates on the cap) is in parentheses after the ingredient.
  • (see product 4601512006724 m): same, but no comma ("или" means "or"), and there is an asterisk after the letter.

Variable nutrition data

Products whose recipe has changed

Products for which the barcode stays the same, but package, ingredients or nutritional values changed.

Products with american nutritional label in Europe

Other

Products compared with European regulations

Labeling

On casein and caseinates food

" Without prejudice to Community provisions on food labeling , labeling of casein and caseinates must include:

* For caseinates : the cation or cations ;
* ( ... ) "

(see product 3270160812936 m) labeling of ingredients in this dish prepared on caseinates ( "sodium caseinate") seems correct. fr:Produits_remarquables

Product with a Nutri-Score that has improved over time

Asked a lot by journalists, we should have a couple of examples to showcase

  • Sandwich saumon - 135 g - Sodébo (see product 3242272890751 m)
  • All Activia passed from C to B with the apposition of the nutriscore on their packaging (e.g. Activia au bifidus mangue - Danone - 500 g (4x125g) (see product 3033491325519 m)